How long do I typically wait for an appointment?

One reviewer noted they have been 'always on time with appointments,' suggesting punctual scheduling, though no specific wait-time data is available.

Will I get follow-up after my pet's procedure or blood work?

Positive example: Autumn called the next day after a routine visit. Negative example: one cat owner waited on blood test results and did not receive a callback from the vet despite calling to follow up.

Does the clinic handle emergency situations?

Yes. A cat in anaphylactic shock during a vaccination appointment was rapidly identified and treated by staff, with positive outcome reported.

Montclair Animal Clinic

Updated 2026-07-10 · 1,287 reviewed · 184 listed · Scored from 645 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.8(645) 87 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Verified

Veterinary Dental CareGeneral Veterinary CareLow-Cost & Vaccine ClinicsVeterinary PharmacySurgery & Specialty Care

Services: Veterinary Dental Care, General Veterinary Care, Low-Cost & Vaccine Clinics
Reviews: 645

What recent reviews say

Long-term patients trust Montclair with complex care, from routine vaccines to surgery, praising Dr. Sharkey and the team for genuine compassion and fair value. One reviewer reported insufficient follow-up after blood work and concerns about a prescribed thyroid medication that caused illness, though the broader pattern across 645 reviews shows consistent loyalty and recommendation.

The clinic's strength lies in taking time to explain options, staying calm under pressure, and building lasting relationships with owners. Staff like Autumn and the front desk earn specific praise for personal attention. Surgery, dentistry, and geriatric care feature prominently in feedback. One caveat: post-procedure communication and medication monitoring appear inconsistent in at least one case.

Praised for

compassionate, hands-on vets
kind and caring staff
strong follow-up and communication
fair pricing for quality
skilled emergency response

Watch-outs

poor follow-up on test results
medication side effects not reassessed
high costs for diagnostics

compassionate-staffskilled-vetsgentle-with-animalsclear-communicationcaring-bedside-mannerresponsive-emergency-caregood-with-anxious-petstransparent-pricingknowledgeable-staff

Best for: Owners seeking a compassionate, stable long-term vet who takes time to explain options and handles anxious or elderly pets gently.

Think twice if: Follow-up communication and medication monitoring could lag; request explicit timelines for test results and side effect check-ins.

Strengths

Dr. Sharkey's hands-on, unhurried approach
Fast, accurate emergency response
Personal staff follow-up (same-day calls)
Long-term continuity (patients of 10-15 years)
Value-conscious, avoids unnecessary add-ons

Worth knowing

Dr. Sharkey (primary vet; praised by name in 13 reviews)
Autumn (staff member; named for same-day follow-up call)
Susan salon (grooming/spa service mentioned)
Patients of 10-15 years are common
One cat developed severe anaphylactic reaction during vaccination; clinic responded with rapid identification and treatment

What reviews say by service

General Veterinary Care: Praised for routine care, thorough exams, and explaining options; one report of missed follow-up on blood work results and thyroid medication side effects not reassessed quickly.
Veterinary Dental Care: Susan's salon service generates positive mention for coat/spa care; no specific dental procedure complaints or praise in reviews.
Surgery & Specialty Care: Multiple reviews credit Dr. Sharkey with professional, successful surgery outcomes; one patient drove across the city specifically for surgical care.
Low-Cost & Vaccine Clinics: Vaccinations mentioned as routine service; one owner reported severe allergic reaction during vaccination appointment, which clinic handled rapidly and professionally.
Veterinary Pharmacy: In-house pharmacy listed on website; thyroid medication prescribed but caused side effects; unclear if in-house or external.

How it compares

Rated 4.8 against a 4.57 average across the 110 veterinary dental care businesses listed here.
Has more Google reviews than 81% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Scoring Method

Star rating 86

Review volume 100

Review recency 100

Review sentiment 67

Profile completeness 100

Verification 30

Rating breakdown

604

Common questions

How long do I typically wait for an appointment?: One reviewer noted they have been 'always on time with appointments,' suggesting punctual scheduling, though no specific wait-time data is available.
Will I get follow-up after my pet's procedure or blood work?: Positive example: Autumn called the next day after a routine visit. Negative example: one cat owner waited on blood test results and did not receive a callback from the vet despite calling to follow up.
Does the clinic handle emergency situations?: Yes. A cat in anaphylactic shock during a vaccination appointment was rapidly identified and treated by staff, with positive outcome reported.

Request a quote

Similar veterinarian nearby

Park Hill Veterinary Medical Center

4.3(364)✓ Verified

Long-time customers praise the kindness of most staff and ease of booking appointments, but recent reviews document serious gaps: slow diagnostic turnarounds (3-4 weeks for urgent cases), hidden charges beyond estimates, and inconsistent care due to veterinarian turnover. Multiple reviews flag aggressive upselling and costs 50-200% above competing clinics without commensurate quality.

Veterinary Dental CareLarge Animal & EquineGeneral Veterinary Care

View profile

VCA Park Hill Animal Hospital

4.2(231)✓ Verified

VCA Park Hill draws consistent praise for its veterinarians, especially Dr. Baxter, and for attentive follow-up care via text. Multiple reviewers note speedy scheduling and staff who handle anxious pets well. However, front desk interactions are a sore point: some customers report condescending language, unclear policy explanations, and appointment confusion. Pricing complaints recur; several reviewers cite high costs and pressure to add services, with vaccinations described as significantly pricier than competitors.

Veterinary Dental CareGeneral Veterinary CareLow-Cost & Vaccine Clinics

View profile

Founders Green Animal Hospital

4.8(275)✓ Verified

Reviewers consistently report a warm, genuinely invested team across front desk, techs, and vets. Dr. Mills especially earns praise for deep listening, creativity with anxious pets, and compassionate end-of-life care. Staff call to offer earlier appointments when cases are complex, send follow-up cards, and answer questions thoroughly without pushing expensive tests first. One reviewer had a negative encounter with Dr. Maria Perez in May, describing rapid speech, rudeness, and failure to deliver scheduled treatment. The same reviewer had thriving relationships with Dr. Margolis and other staff before that visit. Overall the clinic shows strong execution in general care, anxiety management, and difficult medical conversations.

General Veterinary CareLow-Cost & Vaccine ClinicsVeterinary Pharmacy

View profile

Montclair Animal Clinic

What recent reviews say

Strengths

Worth knowing

What reviews say by service

How it compares

How we scored this

Rating breakdown

Common questions

Similar veterinarian nearby

Park Hill Veterinary Medical Center

VCA Park Hill Animal Hospital

Founders Green Animal Hospital

Own this business? Get featured